Cigar cutters but which one though?

[Stogiedog]

I am having great difficulty working out which cigar cutter use to for my cigars like many other BOTL I am sure that we have different ring gauge cigars in the humidor. There are many cigar cutters on the market: Guillotines single,double & triple bladed, Punch cutters different sizes, Scissors, V cutters and I am sure there are more. I have read quite a few articles on the net and is it all really down to personal taste? it cannot be with all those different cigar cutters and ring gauge cigars. A good review is posted below simple but quite informative:

http://www.ehow.com/how_2044218_properly-cut-cigar.html (http://www.ehow.com/how_2044218_properly-cut-cigar.html)

I would be interested to hear what other BOTL use to cut ther cigars and why? Do you get a better draw using a different type of cutter for different ring gauge cigar or is it all for one, one for all?

I currently use a single bladed action Guillotine for all my cuts, however, I will be purchasing a double guillotine shortly.

Paul

[daverave999]

I've wondered about this myself. I've been using a cheapy double-bladed guillotine from ebay (http://stores.ebay.co.uk/greensofleeds) and bought a cheap punch in Newquay last weekend. Coudn't tell any difference in draw or taste in all honesty, apart from I had less bits of tobacco in my mouth at the start with the punch, though I've started tapping them out before I smoke now :tongue:
I'm thinking about getting a bigger gauge punch as it was very neat. I've seen the Wolf double magnetic one claimed to have 30 and 42 gauge cutters, though I've only seen that mentioned in one place (http://www.cigarextras.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=1766).

[Rufus T. Firefly]

I use a double bladed guillotine cutter my self. I've tried punches and a few V-cutters. I just find that I enjoy how a double bladed guillotine cutter opens up the cigar and improves the draw, while giving you a clean cut.

[Lou3]

I've been using a Tsuge double blade for the past several years, but don't like getting the leftover bits of tobacco in my mouth (happens with all guillotine cutters). I recently tried a friend's punch and liked the neater opening and lack of tobacco bits. I'm going to buy one.

[TJCoro]

Lou3,

I also prefer the punch to the cutter for the reasons you mention. I like the way it leave most of the cap intact and has a clean, smooth feel on the lips, without shreds of tobacco. Do a little research before you buy and be sure to get one with a sharp blade, it makes all the difference. A good punch will require very little pressure and twisting to remove the outer skin of the cap.

There are several cheap ones available that work okay, but quickly dull and result in damaging the cap. I recommend that you pay a little more to get a punch that will serve you well. :41:

I have to admit, however, that I am very pleased with the cutter I purchased from Cuban Crafter, as mentioned on another thread started by Robusto. :proud:

[Robusto]

Should be over from the US soon. I'm watching the post!

[TJCoro]

Where will you be going? I may also be going to the reality state :usa: soon myself. :plane:

I know a great place in the Capital City:usa2: where you can still enjoy a fine puro along with lunch or dinner. :bandit:

[Robusto]

http://i67.photobucket.com/albums/h304/elton1984/ABCD0005-5.jpg?t=1234796784

This just arrived. Can't wait to snip one off!

[Stogiedog]

I have to say they look the buisness!! :smile: I have also ordered the same cutters they should be here within a few days! I would be interested to hear how they cut Robusto.

I also think that I will research and buy a cigar punch or v cutter as I smoke quite a few petit coronas. I have read a few articles that recommend punches \ v cutters for petit coronas.

[TJCoro]

That's the one, mate!

I love it! :becky: Just remember to hold the head firmly against the cutter when you snip it. Let us know how you like it.

After using it on several different size puros, I may be a converted punch hombre, but not bloody likely.:noidea:

PS - did they send you a free stoogie with your order? I got a one with mine, but based on the overwelming bad reviews, I likely won't smoke it too soon.

[TJCoro]

:hmmmm: I'm not sure I agree with the articles, compradre stogiedog.

From my own experience, I have found that the smaller the ring size, the more likely you will damage the wrapper with a punch, especially if you are using one that does not have a high quality, sharp blade.

Generally, I use my punch on the bigger puros and save the cutter for the smaller ones, like the Tinidad Reyes and Cohiba Secreto. Although I have used a punch on the smaller puros, the one I use is extremely sharp and I take great care in lining up the punch.

Regarding V cutters - I have found them to be fun and different, but they do not cut very well, not nearly as well as a good punch or a double bladed cutter. The one I used tore the bottom of the cigar, but it wasn't a high quality V cutter either, so who knows. :bandit:

[Robusto]

No free stogie in the pack, alas.
But a decent hand-written thank you card with the purchase.
I may 'break her in' with The Wing in London on unadulterated cigar business tomorrow. :biggrin1:

But I'll probably snip and three-match a porky one after the second Coronation Street tonight.

[emeraldisle]

Bryan,

Cool cutter by the way, even though it looks like something you might see in an opticians perhaps, a new kind of optical instrumentation.

Gabriel

[nicwing]

I am here to confirm that Bryan's new high tech cutter is the dogs danglies. Cut mine with it on Tuesday, took a little getting used to but a great clean cut.

Thought you might like a picture of my latest cutter which was a present from a friend for my birthday. Horny ain't it>

[Stogiedog]

Thanks TJ for your comments and suggestions. I have purchased a double blade guillotine from Cuban Crafters the same as Robusto I await its arrival. I think I will look into purchasing a v cutter they seem to be quite reasonably priced, so that even if I cannot get on with the cutter I haven't lost a great deal. Oh, by the way TJ hope to be on the April get together in London (work permitting), I was interested to read your comments about flying over?

[Robusto]

Hey S Dawg

Can you keep me in the loop if you find a link for a decent V cutter, please?

[Stogiedog]

I surely can Mr Rob Usto.:bounce:

I have had my eye on this one for a while still hunting around at the moment. Let me now your thoughts on this Wolf V cutter mate!

http://www.regalcigars.com/subproduct.php?ID=1447&type=

The dog.:41:

[TJCoro]

:bandit: Names TJ, TJCoro, at your service, Stogiedog,

Glad to help out. The "V" cutters are cheap and fun to have in your collection. Enjoy the Cuban Crafter cutter. It's excellent, IMO, and reasonably priced, too, At least I think so.:dontknow:

I don't remember who was first to mention the Cuban Crafter cutter on this forum, but whoever it was, well done, sir.:top:

Let me know how you like the Wolf V cutter.

Good bye for now from the great State of Mind, Mexico :shakehands:

[daverave999]

Just out of interest TJCoro, what punch do you use?

[TJCoro]

Just out of interest TJCoro, what punch do you use?

:typing:Excellent question, Senor Dave, excellent question.

I have used a number of punches over the years, but the best were those made by "Bull's Eye," a company famous for the bullet-style ejector punch. Unfortunatley, the model I use is no longer available - a lovely Burl Wood, gold plated punch that does not include an ejector, as does the bullet style. It's very elegant and sharp and I use it on my very best puros. :nerd:

A few years ago when I needed to replace the blade, I learned that the burl wood model was discontinued :eek: So I contacted the company's owner directly who was kind enough to send me the few she had left. I was blown away by her generosity!!! I offered her $$$$, but she wouldn't hear of it...not even for the postage. What an angel :love:

There are many cigar punches on the market - some good, some not so good - but the ones I am familiar with and recommend are those made by "Bull's Eye.":top:

Remember - you get what you pay for. So if you decide to get a punch, get a good one. The cheap ones are not very sharp and quickly dull beyond use.

Thanks for asking, senor Dave. I hope you find this information helpful. :typing:


Names TJCoro, at your service.:bandit:

[cohibaIV]

:typing:Excellent question, Senor Dave, excellent question.

I have used a number of punches over the years, but the best were those made by "Bull's Eye," a company famous for the bullet-style ejector punch. Unfortunatley, the model I use is no longer available - a lovely Burl Wood punch that does not include an ejector, as does the bullet style. It's very elegant and sharp and I use it on my very best puros. :nerd:

A few years ago when I needed to replace the blade, I learned that the burl wood model was discontinued :eek: So I contacted the company's owner directly who was kind enough to send me the few she had left. I was blown away by her generosity!!! I offered her $$$$, but she wouldn't hear of it...not even for the postage. What an angel :love:

There are many cigar punches on the market - some good, some not so good - but the ones I am familiar with and recommend are those made by "Bull's Eye.":top:

Remember - you get what you pay for. So if you decide to get a punch, get a good one. The cheap ones are not very sharp and quickly dull beyond use.

Thanks for asking, senor Dave. I hope you find this information helpful. :typing:


Names TJCoro, at your service.:bandit:


TJ

Never used a Punch cutter, so any pointers or advise??:cool:

(Do you stab and twist or twist and stab ect???):confused:

CIV

[TJCoro]

:becky:Glad you asked, senor IV,

Proper technique is very important when using a punch, but quite simple, actually. :willy:

:nerd:First, start with a quality punch, and by that I mean one with a sharp blade. Otherwise, you are wasting your time and won't appreciate the untimate pleasure derived from a properly punched puro.

:nerd:Next, place the punch on the head of the puro, and with a firm but gentle twisting action, begin to apply pressure; just enough to cut the cap. You don't need to drive the punch very deep, just enough to remove the cap and expose the filler.

:nerd:Done correctly, you will be rewarded with a nice clean hole and the majority of the cap intact.

Give 'er a go and let me know what you think:41:

Good Luck, amigo! :rock:

Names TJ, TJCoro, at your service:bandit:

[shed17]

Interesting, I used to use a V cutter years ago but found that it as only good on the smaller ring gauges. Mostly use a Dunhill guillotine however do have a couple of punches, one on the bottom of one of my cigar lighters which has come in handy:biggrin1:

[TJCoro]

:( Ooops! Message deleted. Accidental double post.

Q: Is there a way to remove a post?

[daverave999]

TJ, do you moisten the cap before you use the punch?

[TJCoro]

TJ, do you moisten the cap before you use the punch?


:eek::eek::eek: No,No, No!!! Never, Never, Never!!!:nono: :nono::nono:

You need a nice firm head to provide sufficient resistance to achieve as nice clean cut with the punch. :41:

:willy:Same holds true for cutters - Never moisten the head before cutting a puro. :damnmate:

:argh:And let me further submit that you should never, never moisten the entire length of a stogie by running it in your mouth or any other moist areas, Mr. Clinton. That's just something done in American Westerns :cowboyic9:(movies) or with cheap cigars, which, of course, no one here smokes.:withstupid:

Names TJ Coro, at your service.:bandit:

[daverave999]

:argh:And let me further submit that you should never, ever moisten the entire length of a stogie by running it in your mouth or any other moist areas, Mr. Clinton.

:biggrin1:

I just wanted to check as I'd read it a couple of places. I tried it the once but it seemed so unhelpful that I was unlikely to try it again! Thought it would be worthwhile asking a punch fan. Thanks!

[cohibaIV]

:becky:Glad you asked, senor IV,

Proper technique is very important when using a punch, but quite simple, actually. :willy:

:nerd:First, start with a quality punch, and by that I mean one with a sharp blade. Otherwise, you are wasting your time and won't appreciate the untimate pleasure derived from a properly punched puro.

:nerd:Next, place the punch on the head of the puro, and with a firm but gentle twisting action, begin to apply pressure; just enough to cut the cap. You don't need to drive the punch very deep, just enough to remove the cap and expose the filler.

:nerd:Done correctly, you will be rewarded with a nice clean hole and the majority of the cap intact.

Give 'er a go and let me know what you think:41:

Good Luck, amigo! :rock:

Names TJ, TJCoro, at your service:bandit:


Mr TJ

Many thanks for the advise, I am now searching for a decent punch to try the method....:cool:

Can't wait to see how a cigar smokes using this method..:41:

[TJCoro]

Mr TJ

Many thanks for the advise, I am now searching for a decent punch to try the method....:cool:

Can't wait to see how a cigar smokes using this method..:41:

Slow down, Mr IV, slow down...:bolt:

The punch is not a miracle maker:der:. It won't make your Faux Cohibas any better, they will just feel better on your lips (:nono:Please, no comment from funny guy, Mr. Robusto, we all get the joke here :lol:.)

:hmmmm:Who was it who said, "sometimes a cigar is just a cigar?" Well, sometime a punch is just a punch.

I hope you enjoy smoking a punched puro as much as I do.:smile:

:bandit:Names TJ, TJCoro, and I prefer a punch over a cutter, but that's just me.