Monti No4 storage question

[Eggle]

I have been offered a label sealed box of Monticristo No 4 about 3 - 4 years old.
They have been stored in a cupboard.
Will they be ok, or should I pass.
The price is reasonable and I know where they came from and are genuine.

[Stevieboy]

If they've been in a cupboard and not in a humi, the chances are they might be knackered ie dry and flavourless!?!? Open the box first, smoke one then pay if you like it!?!?

[matt257]

If they have been stored without any type of RH regulation I would say they are past it. They could possibly be rehydrated but all the natural oils will have been lost and the flavour along with it

[cj121]

I have been offered a label sealed box of Monticristo No 4 about 3 - 4 years old.
They have been stored in a cupboard.
Will they be ok, or should I pass.
The price is reasonable and I know where they came from and are genuine.

Respectfully pass I reckon Eggle. They'll be buggered probably. Were they the ones advertised on here yesterday out of curiosity?
Stevie's advice is sound, if the chap'll let you dip in.

[whisky77]

Such a waste.

Such a waste, but I would most definitely pass.They didn`t stand a chance.

[larrysputnik]

The only reasonable price for these would be free. Even then I still might pass. Go Pens.