Cigar recommendation thread?

[WDave40]

Ah forgive me - I didn't read the first post fully!

As always looking for CC recommendations, but always open to some nice NCs too!

Favourite cigar to date: Party E2, BBF, Monte No. 4
Least favourite cigar to date: None really
Preferred flavour profile (sweet/creamy/woody etc): Sweet and creamy
Preferred body: Pyramides (or something with a 50+ ring guage - not too familiar with chunky smokes)
Preferred strength: Medium
Minimum/maximum smoking time: 45 mins to 1 hr 30
Budget (per cigar): Up to ?25 for something special

[K444HEP]

Hoyo de Monterrey Epicure No. 2

[MENTION=13453624]WDave40[/MENTION], your turn for a recommendation.

[WDave40]

Hoyo de Monterrey Epicure No. 2

I'll give it a go, still to venture into Cuban territory but sampled a fair few from the NC variety.

Favourite cigar to date: Casa Turrent, Maduro Robusto. Beautiful cinnamon flavours.
Least favourite cigar to date: Henri Wintermans, if you've had one you'll know exactly why.
Preferred flavour profile (sweet/creamy/woody etc): Creamy coffee definitely.
Preferred body: Like vitola? Can't say I have a preference for that as yet but not too keen on the smaller ring gauges.
Preferred strength: Medium to full, the maduro wrappers often get my attention.
Minimum/maximum smoking time: 15minutes to 1 hour.
Budget (per cigar): Usually buy singles and so far the most has been ?16 I think.

[Donny]

I'll give it a go, still to venture into Cuban territory but sampled a fair few from the NC variety.

Favourite cigar to date: Casa Turrent, Maduro Robusto. Beautiful cinnamon flavours.
Least favourite cigar to date: Henri Wintermans, if you've had one you'll know exactly why.
Preferred flavour profile (sweet/creamy/woody etc): Creamy coffee definitely.
Preferred body: Like vitola? Can't say I have a preference for that as yet but not too keen on the smaller ring gauges.
Preferred strength: Medium to full, the maduro wrappers often get my attention.
Minimum/maximum smoking time: 15minutes to 1 hour.
Budget (per cigar): Usually buy singles and so far the most has been ?16 I think.

[anz3001]

O.k. get the ball rolling with your own format and suggestions will come. Whats to lose?

[K444HEP]

Morning All,

I'm not sure if this has been done here previously, so please forgive me if this is a repeat; mods feel free to delete if this is the case.

I was a member of a fragrance forum a while ago and we created a thread where members would recommend different fragrances based on likes/dislikes listed. I wondered if this could work here? Being fairly new to this hobby, I would find this sort of thing both helpful and informative as well as being a bit of fun.

The rule would be that in order to post for a recommendation, you would have to suggest (at least) one cigar for the member above.

Perhaps something like:
Favourite cigar to date:
Least favourite cigar to date:
Preferred flavour profile (sweet/creamy/woody etc):
Preferred body:
Preferred strength:
Minimum/maximum smoking time:
Budget (per cigar):

Thoughts? Obviously those with many years experience would be great at suggesting cigars, though it may be difficult to suggest something for them that they haven't already tried.