I love Punch Punch & have half a cabinet hopefully maturing into great smokes (although I'm not sure I have the patience to wait a further 10 or so years that this would probably require).
The one proviso I'd make is to go for cabinet versions - the only box-pressed I've had was plugged & I bet similar complaints on here have all been regarding this format.
I love/loved petit Punch too & one of the best smokes I've had was a well-aged tubed Churchil.
-
I bought a fiver of Punch Punch from 2003. I have smoked 3 so far. Nothing but a great smoke for me. No plugs and an even burn.Leave a comment:
-
I quite like the punch churchill and last years UK re the d'oro no.1 was AMAZING! put these on your bucket list!Leave a comment:
-
Almost every Punch Punch I've had has been plugged....honest! The frustrating thing is the one or two that weren't plugged tasted fantastic
I also had a box of Punch Black Prince and every single one was plugged....every one! I clipped every one tested then returned them to the seller....Leave a comment:
-
Punch Petit Coronations are a lovely cheaper smoke.
I think I have one left in my humidor...
Well worth a try!
Leave a comment:
-
I've only had the one Punch Punch and that was too tight to give a good verdict. I do love the (sadly now-discontinued) Petit Punch though.Leave a comment:
-
I smoked a Punch Royal Selection No.11 yesterday, it's definately becoming one of my top 3 cigars. It didn't have any construction problem FYILeave a comment:
-
Punch ? Punch Punch
I smoked one of these last night and thought it pretty OK all round and fairly inexpensive. But reading through reviews this seems to be a cigar you either love or hate.
I understand Punch are often dogged by construction issues, so maybe some of the loathing arises from those.
Does anyone have any extreem pro or con views?
Leave a comment: