IT'S A CIGAR KNOCKOUT 2019

[thedame007]

I am disgusted that punch went out so soon! You can tell I missed half of this battle! Punch shall rise again next year!

[Simon Bolivar]

I notice that the Tiempo is conspicuous by its absence - why not rectify this glaring omission [emoji6]

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

Ha, good point but to fresh & too large RG for my tastes :O)

[sheppsea]

I am disgusted that punch went out so soon! You can tell I missed half of this battle! Punch shall rise again next year!

I agree with that too - the list broadly matches what I like, but Punch and Cohiba both went out far too soon

[SHAMZ84]

I agree with that too - the list broadly matches what I like, but Punch and Cohiba both went out far too soon

Cohiba generally go out early

[Emaresee]

Of the 31, i have one or more sticks of 26 of the marcas in my stash.... how about you?

[simwells]

How did punch come in last?!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[ha_banos]

Hmm I think I'm 8 marcas short from that list.

[sheppsea]

Cohiba generally go out early

Yeah I know, and every year I get disappointed at how early goes

[simwells]

Of the 31, i have one or more sticks of 26 of the marcas in my stash.... how about you?

I?ve got 27 of the Marcas just missing four surprisingly!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Kickback]

Surprised Padron didn't end up at the top. One of the highest rated marcas anywhere.

[grumpybaldy]

I have a Box of BBF that?s only a year old so uncracked...

They'll probably be OK; they do smoke well young.

[sheppsea]

Surprised Padron didn't end up at the top. One of the highest rated marcas anywhere.

Its down to being an NC - I genuinely enjoy some good NCs but my favourite cigars have all been CCs. The only NCs really near the top at Opus X

[simwells]

Surprised Padron didn't end up at the top. One of the highest rated marcas anywhere.

NC and expensive though which definitely seemed to mark you down on this one


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[simwells]

IT'S A CIGAR KNOCKOUT 2019

They'll probably be OK; they do smoke well young.

Oh do they? I?d always heard they needed time and I don?t tend to be a fan of younger smokes unless truly fresh and they?re almost impossible to find in the U.K.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[geoffbot]

Cohiba generally go out early

Very expensive cigars! Not sure they're worth the premium.