6+3+1=10

[Wigan]

After giving them a good trying out and working my way through a fair few in the last few months I reckon Non-Cubans come in at

6 naff/mediocre at best
3 alright ones
1 good one
For every 10

Don't really think its worth working through them when Cubans are more like 1 naff one and 9 good ones per 10.

What does everyone else think?

[PeeJay]

I think you need to be more selective with your non-Cubans

[oskihen]

Ditto to that pj

[TonyN]

Can't answer that one wigan only smoke cubans myself, never realy been intrested in non cubans.

[sheppsea]

I don't find it as simple as that - I have had plenty of bad cubans and have found many NCs (certainly much more than 1/10) to be good smokes, the reason I virtually exclusively smoke CCs is that I find the best CCs far better than the best NCs (if I remember correctly my top 20 rated cigars for my first year of smoking were all CCs)

[Wigan]

I think you need to be more selective with your non-Cubans

Half of them have been bombs from you PJ.......


Mind you my fav nc came from you

[PeeJay]

Half of them have been bombs from you PJ.......


Mind you my fav nc came from you

Point proven, you haven't been selecting them giving-the-finger-smiley-emoticon.gif

[Wigan]

Point proven, you haven't been selecting them [ATTACH=CONFIG]23183[/ATTACH]

LOL - literally

[butternutsquashpie]

Half of them have been bombs from you PJ.......

Mind you my fav nc came from you

What were they? Just curious on my end and for those keeping track at home

I've found my little niche when it comes to NCs. I have the list somewhere here...

Davidoff Millennium Series.
ANY A. Fuente - yet to have a bad one. Includes :
-Hemmingway series
-Chateaux
-8XX serie
-Curly heads
-others that I can't remember the name of
LFD Double Ligero Chisel (or any of their other chisels)
La Aurora Preferido Perfectos
Macanudo Maduro Et Al.

In fact, I had a La Aurora Ruby yesterday from kind sire [MENTION=213]TJCoro[/MENTION] that smoked wonderfully! It's nice to have a break from Cuban cigars occasionally. I have a Liga Privada No. 9 in my pocket right now.

[Wigan]

I don't have an xact list of every single one I have smoked. I know I have only had 2 from your list butters

[PeeJay]

I have a Liga Privada No. 9 in my pocket right now.

And I thought you were pleased to see us!

[Wigan]

The RyJ Reserva 1875 Lancero probably makes it into my top 20 of favourite cigars

[butternutsquashpie]

And I thought you were pleased to see us!

Ewwww......

The RyJ Reserva 1875 Lancero probably makes it into my top 20 of favourite cigars

Alright. That's it. I know what to send you... There's no reason a General Cigar company product should be on your top 20 list.
Let's dig around so that you'll REALLY like my next selection.

[groundhog]

So which was your favourite?

[Wigan]

So which was your favourite?

The RyJ Reserva 1875 Lancero probably makes it into my top 20 of favourite cigars

That one