Cigar 'IT'S A KNOCKOUT!'

[mrnutt]

Arturo Fuente - 10

Bolivar - 10

Cohiba - 12

Cuaba - 8

Davidoff - 10

Diplomaticos - 10

El rey del Mundo - 11

Fonseca - 6

H Upmann - 12

Hoyo de Monterrey - 11

Jose L Piedra - 6

Juan Lopez - 11

La Flor de Cano - 10

La Gloria Cubana - 10

Montecristo - 10

Padron - 6

Partagas -9

Por Larranaga - 11

Punch - 10

Quai D'Orsay - 10

Quinteros - 6

Rafael Gonzales - 8

Ramon Allones - 10

Romeo y Julieta - 10

San Luis Rey - 10

San Cristobal de la Habana - 11

Sancho Panza - 10

Trinidad - 11

Vegas Robaina - 10

Vegueros - 10


I think i've done this right, forgive me if not i've not done this before

[potpest]

Arturo Fuente - 10

Bolivar - 10

Cohiba - 12

Cuaba - 8

Davidoff - 10

Diplomaticos - 10

El rey del Mundo - 11

Fonseca - 6

H Upmann - 11

Hoyo de Monterrey - 11

Jose L Piedra - 6

Juan Lopez - 11

La Flor de Cano - 10

La Gloria Cubana - 10

Montecristo - 10

Padron - 6

Partagas -9

Por Larranaga - 11

Punch - 10

Quai D'Orsay - 10

Quinteros - 8

Rafael Gonzales - 8

Ramon Allones - 10

Romeo y Julieta - 10

San Luis Rey - 10

San Cristobal de la Habana - 11

Sancho Panza - 10

Trinidad - 11

Vegas Robaina - 10

Vegueros - 10

[SHAMZ84]

**corrections added: missed items from list, and previous votes dropped off**



Arturo Fuente - 10

Bolivar - 10

Cohiba - 10

Cuaba - 10

Davidoff - 10

Diplomaticos - 10

El rey del Mundo - 11

Fonseca - 8

H Upmann - 11

Hoyo de Monterrey - 10

Jose L Piedra - 10

Juan Lopez - 10

La Flor de Cano - 10

La Gloria Cubana - 10

Montecristo - 10

Padron - 10

Partagas - 8

Por Larranaga - 10

Punch - 10

Quai D'Orsay - 10

Quinteros - 10

Rafael Gonzales - 8

Ramon Allones - 10

Romeo y Julieta - 10

San Luis Rey - 10

San Cristobal de la Habana - 10

Sancho Panza - 10

Trinidad - 11

Vegas Robaina - 10

Vegueros - 10

Cheers Greg...I forgot it was +1 and -2



Sham


Sent from my ONEPLUS A3003 using Tapatalk

[PeeJay]

Arturo Fuente - 10

Bolivar - 10

Cohiba - 11

Cuaba - 8

Davidoff - 10

Diplomaticos - 10

El rey del Mundo - 11

Fonseca - 6

H Upmann - 11

Hoyo de Monterrey - 11

Jose L Piedra - 6

Juan Lopez - 11

La Flor de Cano - 10

La Gloria Cubana - 10

Montecristo - 10

Padron - 6

Partagas -9

Por Larranaga - 11

Punch - 10

Quai D'Orsay - 10

Quinteros - 10

Rafael Gonzales - 8

Ramon Allones - 10

Romeo y Julieta - 10

San Luis Rey - 10

San Cristobal de la Habana - 11

Sancho Panza - 10

Trinidad - 11

Vegas Robaina - 10

Vegueros - 10

[thedame007]

***Correction: taken 2 off Cuaba***


Bolivar - 10

Cohiba - 11

Cuaba - 8

Davidoff - 10

Diplomaticos - 10

El rey del Mundo - 11

Fonseca - 6

H Upmann - 11

Hoyo de Monterrey - 11

Jose L Piedra - 8

Juan Lopez - 10

La Flor de Cano - 10

La Gloria Cubana - 10

Montecristo - 10

Padron - 6

Partagas - 9

Por Larranaga - 11

Punch - 10

Quai D'Orsay - 10

Quinteros - 10

Rafael Gonzales - 8

Ramon Allones - 10

Romeo y Julieta - 10

San Luis Rey - 10

San Cristobal de la Habana - 11

Sancho Panza - 10

Trinidad - 11

Vegas Robaina - 10

Vegueros - 10

[SHAMZ84]

Arturo Fuente - 10

Bolivar - 10

Cohiba - 11

Cuaba - 9

Davidoff - 10

Diplomaticos - 10

El rey del Mundo - 11

Fonseca - 6

H Upmann - 11

Hoyo de Monterrey - 11

Jose L Piedra - 8

Juan Lopez - 10

La Flor de Cano - 10

La Gloria Cubana - 10

Montecristo - 10

Padron - 6

Partagas - 9

Por Larranaga - 11

Punch - 10

Quai D'Orsay - 10

Quinteros - 10

Rafael Gonzales - 8

Ramon Allones - 10

Romeo y Julieta - 10

San Luis Rey - 10

San Cristobal de la Habana - 11

Sancho Panza - 10

Trinidad - 11

Vegas Robaina - 10

Vegueros - 10


Sent from my ONEPLUS A3003 using Tapatalk

[thedame007]

+ Por Larranaga
- Fonseca

Don't recall ever having smoked a Padron or Davidoff and possibly only one or two A Fuente.

Arturo Fuente - 10

Bolivar - 10

Cohiba - 11

Cuaba - 10

Davidoff - 10

Diplomaticos - 10

El rey del Mundo - 11

Fonseca - 6

H Upmann - 11

Hoyo de Monterrey - 11

Jose L Piedra - 8

Juan Lopez - 10

La Flor de Cano - 10

La Gloria Cubana - 10

Montecristo - 10

Padron - 6

Partagas - 8

Por Larranaga - 11

Punch - 10

Quai D'Orsay - 10

Quinteros - 10

Rafael Gonzales - 8

Ramon Allones - 10

Romeo y Julieta - 10

San Luis Rey - 10

San Cristobal de la Habana - 11

Sancho Panza - 10

Trinidad - 11

Vegas Robaina - 10

Vegueros - 10

[ValeTudoGuy]

+ Por Larranaga
- Fonseca

Don't recall ever having smoked a Padron or Davidoff and possibly only one or two A Fuente.

[gojira]

Cool, I love it when this comes up. Like every year it will be tough for me to chose a favourite marca and I like saving Cohiba (nowadays almost all cigars are expensive and a good Cohiba with a little age on it is something special IMO), so here we go:

Arturo Fuente - 10

Bolivar - 10

Cohiba - 11

Cuaba - 10

Davidoff - 10

Diplomaticos - 10

El rey del Mundo - 11

Fonseca - 8

H Upmann - 11

Hoyo de Monterrey - 11

Jose L Piedra - 8
Juan Lopez - 10

La Flor de Cano - 10

La Gloria Cubana - 10

Montecristo - 10

Padron - 6

Partagas - 8

Por Larranaga - 10

Punch - 10

Quai D'Orsay - 10

Quinteros - 10

Rafael Gonzales - 8

Ramon Allones - 10

Romeo y Julieta - 10

San Luis Rey - 10

San Cristobal de la Habana - 11

Sancho Panza - 10

Trinidad - 11

Vegas Robaina - 10

Vegueros - 10

[K444HEP]

If i recall, last year they went out about the halfway mark - i guess the premium cost inflicted their true value for members

Good point, certainly better out there for the money IMO.

[thedame007]

I know it's early days in this thread, but interesting that Cohiba has not yet received any votes given the way they are lauded on social media

If i recall, last year they went out about the halfway mark - i guess the premium cost inflicted their true value for members

[K444HEP]

I know it's early days in this thread, but interesting that Cohiba has not yet received any votes given the way they are lauded on social media

[thedame007]

**Cleared block bold to show votes made**

Arturo Fuente - 10

Bolivar - 10

Cohiba - 10

Cuaba - 10

Davidoff - 10

Diplomaticos - 10

El rey del Mundo - 11

Fonseca - 8

H Upmann - 11

Hoyo de Monterrey - 11

Jose L Piedra - 8

Juan Lopez - 10

La Flor de Cano - 10

La Gloria Cubana - 10

Montecristo - 10

Padron - 8

Partagas - 8

Por Larranaga - 10

Punch - 10

Quai D'Orsay - 10

Quinteros - 10

Rafael Gonzales - 8

Ramon Allones - 10

Romeo y Julieta - 10

San Luis Rey - 10

San Cristobal de la Habana - 11

Sancho Panza - 10

Trinidad - 11

Vegas Robaina - 10

Vegueros - 10

[moteyi]

Arturo Fuente - 10

Bolivar - 10

Cohiba - 10

Cuaba - 10

Davidoff - 10

Diplomaticos - 10

El rey del Mundo - 11

Fonseca - 8

H Upmann - 11

Hoyo de Monterrey - 11

Jose L Piedra - 8

Juan Lopez - 10

La Flor de Cano - 10

La Gloria Cubana - 10

Montecristo - 10

Padron - 8

Partagas - 8

Por Larranaga - 10

Punch - 10

Quai D'Orsay - 10

Quinteros - 10

Rafael Gonzales - 8

Ramon Allones - 10

Romeo y Julieta - 10

San Luis Rey - 10

San Cristobal de la Habana - 11

Sancho Panza - 10

Trinidad - 11

Vegas Robaina - 10

Vegueros - 10

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

[Emaresee]

Arturo Fuente - 10

Bolivar - 10

Cohiba - 10

Cuaba - 10

Davidoff - 10

Diplomaticos - 10

El rey del Mundo - 11

Fonseca - 8

H Upmann - 11

Hoyo de Monterrey - 10

Jose L Piedra - 10

Juan Lopez - 10

La Flor de Cano - 10

La Gloria Cubana - 10

Montecristo - 10

Padron - 8

Partagas - 8

Por Larranaga - 10

Punch - 10

Quai D'Orsay - 10

Quinteros - 10

Rafael Gonzales - 8

Ramon Allones - 10

Romeo y Julieta - 10

San Luis Rey - 10

San Cristobal de la Habana - 11

Sancho Panza - 10

Trinidad - 11

Vegas Robaina - 10

Vegueros - 10