Cigar 'IT'S A KNOCKOUT!'

[Marbleman85]

+1 Bolivar

-2 Trinidad

Bolivar - 8

El rey del Mundo - 11

H Upmann - 4

Por Larranaga - 10

Ramon Allones - 1

Trinidad - 9

Sent from my LG-M250 using Tapatalk

[PeeJay]

Bolivar - 7

El rey del Mundo - 11

H Upmann - 4

Por Larranaga - 10

Ramon Allones - 1

Trinidad - 11

[Vitola]

Bolivar - 6

El rey del Mundo - 13

H Upmann - 4

Por Larranaga - 10

Ramon Allones - 1

Trinidad - 11

[gojira]

an aged Choix Supreme is just a delight to smoke. mellow, smooth, tasty and no nonsense. Wont be to the liking of anyone who just sticks to the blockbuster big flavour profiles, it's much more subtle and enjoyable IMHO.

I agree with you Matt. I have come to appreciate those under the radar marcas more and more. I like the bigger marcas of course but those ERdM, LGC QdO and SCdLH ar special smokes, especially with some age on them.

[ha_banos]

an aged Choix Supreme is just a delight to smoke. mellow, smooth, tasty and no nonsense. Wont be to the liking of anyone who just sticks to the blockbuster big flavour profiles, it's much more subtle and enjoyable IMHO.

Yup yup. Agreed. Got a couple of fivers of different age so far.

[Emaresee]

Yup. Those are included in the raries!

an aged Choix Supreme is just a delight to smoke. mellow, smooth, tasty and no nonsense. Wont be to the liking of anyone who just sticks to the blockbuster big flavour profiles, it's much more subtle and enjoyable IMHO.

[ha_banos]

Or regionals; some of them are very good.

Yup. Those are included in the raries!

[gojira]

Does make me want to try more ERDM but there's only 2 cigars in production! [emoji16]

So I have to go hunt raries!? [emoji19]

Or regionals; some of them are very good.

[ha_banos]

Does make me want to try more ERDM but there's only 2 cigars in production! [emoji16]

So I have to go hunt raries!? [emoji19]

[Emaresee]

This is why I've set back this year. I've generally enjoyed all marcas! Yes there have been some not so good or not to my taste sticks. But even these vary for each marca.

So just watching the show..... #popcorn

my two stellar smokes of last year were Fonseca and Cohiba... these fell early-ish.

But there is still a favoured marca in the mix, and some runners up!

[ha_banos]

Yes, definitely. Don't know yet what I will vote against tomorrow.

This is why I've set back this year. I've generally enjoyed all marcas! Yes there have been some not so good or not to my taste sticks. But even these vary for each marca.

So just watching the show..... #popcorn

[K444HEP]

For Simon:

Bolivar - 6

El rey del Mundo - 13

H Upmann - 6

Por Larranaga - 10

Ramon Allones - 1

Trinidad - 10

[gojira]

This is getting very interesting... does anyone else feel slight guilt as you apply your minus points?! I genuinely enjoy all of the marcas that are left, so it starts to come down to what I have smoked less of at this stage rather than good/bad/indifferent.

Yes, definitely. Don't know yet what I will vote against tomorrow.

[Simon Bolivar]

ERDM +
H.Up -

[K444HEP]

This is getting very interesting... does anyone else feel slight guilt as you apply your minus points?! I genuinely enjoy all of the marcas that are left, so it starts to come down to what I have smoked less of at this stage rather than good/bad/indifferent.