Monte Petit No.2 vs Petit Edmundo

[simwells]

Hi,

I'm tempted to pick up a 10 box of some Monte cigars, but so far have only tried a no.1 and no.2. The no.2 was definitely the stand out of the two but is a longer smoke than I tend to prefer.

How would people compare the Petit No.2 and Petit Edmundo? Is the Petit No.2 generally seen as the better cigar?

[gojira]

I don't know, never had a Petit No.2. The PE however can be a very good cigar if you manage to get a good box and keep your fingers off it for 3 or 4 years.

[JoeyGunz]

The P.E is generally regarded as the better of the two, I only had OR Petit No.2's but I wasn't impressed.

[puropunch]

Not tried the petite 2 but I can recommend the pe

Not much help tho I suppose

[simwells]

All opinions are interesting to hear, sounds like the PE then. The other has a higher review on c.gars but I guess that heavily depends on who's reviewed it

[ha_banos]

Beware the opinions....

[Hookmaker]

Try no. 4, it’s a classic, and not that long a smoke

[simwells]

Try no. 4, it’s a classic, and not that long a smoke

More options doesn't make this easier! There's quite a list growing

[Moley]

PE is a great cigar. I love the no 4. Both great smokes

[Stevieboy]

I've smoked loads of PE & PNo2 and both are excellent. I'm slightly more partial to the Petit No2 these days and I actually prefer them to the full-size No2.... Great cigar

[simwells]

Sounds like I might just be picking this one out the hat then!

[TJCoro]

Take the puro and run!

Good question, chico...

Like others, I?ve smoked a few of these fine puros in the past and find them both good smokes. But if pushed to choose one, I?d go with the Petit Edmundo.


Ray Jay

[Emaresee]

I've smoked loads of PE & PNo2 and both are excellent. I'm slightly more partial to the Petit No2 these days and I actually prefer them to the full-size No2.... Great cigar

Ah stevie... cut from the same cloth. Have enjoyed both. and a P.No2 only last weekend. I am batting 50:50 on PE's - when they are good they are great, but can be prone to iffy construction.
its the mini pyramides I prefer for sure..

[Alexw33]

Go for the No. 5

[simwells]

Guess I might need to get used to asking for a choice between two sticks and ending up with 5 boxes?!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk