BGMs .... 07s or 08s ..... hmmmm that

[tippexx]

is the question?

Age usually is best, so why am I hesitant what's niggling?

[senor_robusto]

hey arf,i've 2 boxes of 2007's that are fantastic! i've smoked 2 out of each box, plus i bought a handful from andy (ammc)...... these were also 2007's!!! the one i had the othernight from andy (bigboned) was from 2008, it was fantastic!!! as good as, no better than, the 2007's!!! saying that, it is an amazing cigar imo!!! get 'em while you can mate, no matter the year!!!alex

[Bigboned]

Agreed get em all! ( lol ask for discount for old stock - u never know lmao)

[monkey66]

The 07's are great, I have yet to crack into my '08s but as a great year in general I can only imagine they are great too. Don't over think it, I suspect all good

[TJCoro]

Blind Test!

Word on the street is that the '08s are the better of the two. Maybe so. I have boxes of each year and I can't really tell the difference... unless I look at the box date!


Boy, Bag Boy


(Hurumph!) I'm a bit partial to the '08s, myself.


Haha! WHO talks like that, el P?

[tippexx]

That's the rumour I've been hearin' TJ. I have to say the 08' I got from Deano was one of my best ever smokes.

Gonna have to make my mind up .... 'cos sure as hell there aint gonna be any 11s or 12s.

[Bad-Yeti]

Tried both and couldn't say that either are any better that the other.

[Zigatoh]

Had one bigboned sent me only the other day and I don't know what year it was but I'm getting some, and honestly, I don't care what year, one way or another they're ruddy good smokes!

[Detroit_Waves]

Couldn't you get both boxes Tip, and sell half from each? Get the best of both worlds then, a side my side comparison of both years! Obviously, youll run out of your favourite a lot quicker...but you can just smoke the year you prefer least first...knowing youve got your preferred year to come in a few years time!

By all accounts, it sounds like both years are winners. I've only had a 2008, and that was superb. I need to get a box of either year in the new year hopefully, whilst I still can!