Your favourite Cuban

[Wigan]

Could I please vote for HdM and against Bolivar (sacrilege, I know)

For curiosity sake, why do rank bolivar as your least fav brand?

[sheppsea]

Ramon Allones doing well. Never had one. What would be a recommended stick of theirs??

Ramon Allones Specially Selected is an outstanding cigar, as is the Small Club Corona, so I would recommend both of those

For Upmann. Against Sancho Panza.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Done

Bolivar - 10
Cohiba - 5
Dplomaticos - 4
El Rey del Mundo - 6
H Upmann - 4
Hoyo de Monterrey - 10
Juan Lopez - 3
La Gloria Cubana - 4
Montecristo - 8
Partagas - 9
Por Larranaga - 7
Punch - 6
Rafael Gonzalez - 7
Ramon Allones - 14
Romeo y Julieta - 7
Saint Luis Rey - 6
San Cristobal de La Habana - 6


Out


18 Sancho Panza
19 Quintero
20 La Flor De Cano
21 Vegueros
22 Vegas Robaina
23 Trinidad
24 Cuaba
25 Fonseca
26 Quai d'Orsay
27 Jose L Pedra

[parnaby]

For Upmann. Against Sancho Panza.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Matt1979]

Ramon Allones doing well. Never had one. What would be a recommended stick of theirs??

[sheppsea]

Ra + 1 h upmann -2

Done



Bolivar - 10
Cohiba - 5
Dplomaticos - 4
El Rey del Mundo - 6
H Upmann - 3
Hoyo de Monterrey - 10
Juan Lopez - 3
La Gloria Cubana - 4
Montecristo - 8
Partagas - 9
Por Larranaga - 7
Punch - 6
Rafael Gonzalez - 7
Ramon Allones - 14
Romeo y Julieta - 7
Saint Luis Rey - 6
San Cristobal de La Habana - 6
Sancho Panza - 1

Out

19 Quintero
20 La Flor De Cano
21 Vegueros
22 Vegas Robaina
23 Trinidad
24 Cuaba
25 Fonseca
26 Quai d'Orsay
27 Jose L Pedra

[oskihen]

Ra + 1 h upmann -2

[cigarmo]

Bolivar - 10
Cohiba - 5
Dplomaticos - 4
El Rey del Mundo - 6
H Upmann - 5
Hoyo de Monterrey - 10
Juan Lopez - 3
La Gloria Cubana - 4
Montecristo - 8
Partagas - 9
Por Larranaga - 7
Punch - 6
Rafael Gonzalez - 7
Ramon Allones - 13
Romeo y Julieta - 7
Saint Luis Rey - 6
San Cristobal de La Habana - 6
Sancho Panza - 1

[sheppsea]

Is it +1 and -2?

Yep

[sheppsea]

Just updating the out list now that Quintero is gone.


I think its fine to split our negative vote if there is only one point left for something (unless John can think of a problem?), we just need to avoid splitting it generally - it gets too easy to save brands otherwise and we'll end in a stalemate and it'll loose momentum


Bolivar - 10
Cohiba - 5
Dplomaticos - 4
El Rey del Mundo - 6
H Upmann - 5
Hoyo de Monterrey - 10
Juan Lopez - 3
La Gloria Cubana - 6
Montecristo - 7
Partagas - 9
Por Larranaga - 7
Punch - 6
Rafael Gonzalez - 7
Ramon Allones - 13
Romeo y Julieta - 7
Saint Luis Rey - 6
San Cristobal de La Habana - 6
Sancho Panza - 1

Out

19 Quintero
20 La Flor De Cano
21 Vegueros
22 Vegas Robaina
23 Trinidad
24 Cuaba
25 Fonseca
26 Quai d'Orsay
27 Jose L Pedra

[cigarmo]

Is it +1 and -2?

[Emaresee]

Bolivar - 10
Cohiba - 5
Dplomaticos - 4El Rey del Mundo - 6
H Upmann - 5
Hoyo de Monterrey - 10
Juan Lopez - 3
La Gloria Cubana - 6
Montecristo - 7
Partagas - 9
Por Larranaga - 7
Punch - 6
Quintero - 0
Rafael Gonzalez - 7
Ramon Allones - 13
Romeo y Julieta - 7
Saint Luis Rey - 6
San Cristobal de La Habana - 6
Sancho Panza - 1

[Simon Bolivar]

Quintero -1 & Sancho Panza -1, +1 Cohiba
Bolivar - 10
Cohiba - 5
Dplomaticos - 4El Rey del Mundo - 6
H Upmann - 5
Hoyo de Monterrey - 9
Juan Lopez - 3
La Gloria Cubana - 6
Montecristo - 7
Partagas - 9
Por Larranaga - 7
Punch - 6
Quintero - 0
Rafael Gonzalez - 7
Ramon Allones - 13
Romeo y Julieta - 7
Saint Luis Rey - 6
San Cristobal de La Habana - 6
Sancho Panza - 3

[sheppsea]

Plus 1 for Cohiba; they may be expensive but they do offer something other sticks don't, and minus 2 for Dippy; I know some mourn their demise, but I don't

Bolivar - 10
Cohiba - 4
Diplomaticos - 4
El Rey del Mundo - 6
H Upmann - 5
Hoyo de Monterrey - 9
Juan Lopez - 3
La Gloria Cubana - 6
Montecristo - 7
Partagas - 9
Por Larranaga - 7
Punch - 6
Quintero - 1
Rafael Gonzalez - 7
Ramon Allones - 13
Romeo y Julieta - 7
Saint Luis Rey - 6
San Cristobal de La Habana - 6
Sancho Panza - 4


Out


20 La Flor De Cano
21 Vegueros
22 Vegas Robaina
23 Trinidad
24 Cuaba
25 Fonseca
26 Quai d'Orsay
27 Jose L Pedra

[PeeJay]

New day!

Bolivar - 10
Cohiba - 3
Diplomaticos - 6
El Rey del Mundo - 6
H Upmann - 5
Hoyo de Monterrey - 9
Juan Lopez - 3
La Gloria Cubana - 6
Montecristo - 7
Partagas - 9
Por Larranaga - 7
Punch - 6
Quintero - 1
Rafael Gonzalez - 7
Ramon Allones - 13
Romeo y Julieta - 7
Saint Luis Rey - 6
San Cristobal de La Habana - 6
Sancho Panza - 4

Out

20 La Flor De Cano
21 Vegueros
22 Vegas Robaina
23 Trinidad
24 Cuaba
25 Fonseca
26 Quai d'Orsay
27 Jose L Pedra

[sheppsea]

Could I please vote for HdM and against Bolivar (sacrilege, I know)

Done

Bolivar - 10
Cohiba - 3
Diplomaticos - 6
El Rey del Mundo - 6
H Upmann - 5
Hoyo de Monterrey - 8
Juan Lopez - 3
La Gloria Cubana - 6
Montecristo - 7
Partagas - 9
Por Larranaga - 7
Punch - 6
Quintero - 1
Rafael Gonzalez - 7
Ramon Allones - 13
Romeo y Julieta - 7
Saint Luis Rey - 6
San Cristobal de La Habana - 6
Sancho Panza - 6

Out

20 La Flor De Cano
21 Vegueros
22 Vegas Robaina
23 Trinidad
24 Cuaba
25 Fonseca
26 Quai d'Orsay
27 Jose L Pedra