Your favourite Cuban

[sheppsea]

No criticism of you Jim but I think in future if someone misses a day then the opportunity is lost else someone could wipe out a vulnerable brand in one fell swoop.

Good point - hadn't thought of that

[PeeJay]

I missed voting yesterday so I'll have 2 for Ramon allones and four off hdm

No criticism of you Jim but I think in future if someone misses a day then the opportunity is lost else someone could wipe out a vulnerable brand in one fell swoop.

[sheppsea]

For today I'd to vote FOR Quinteros for it being a wonderful smoke for the price. And against Vegueros.

Vegueros is already gone - what is your next least favourite?

[PeeJay]

Are the vegueros no good generally or is it because they are still young? Not tried one myself.

Probably haven't been around long enough to establish themselves, I like them

[sheppsea]

You need to take two off your least favourite Simon - corrected version below. I have also moved all those knocked out already to another list underneath in 'rank' order, if you all feel it better to move it back to how it was let me know

Bolivar - 12
Cohiba - 3
Diplomaticos - 6
El Rey del Mundo - 6
H Upmann - 5
Hoyo de Monterrey - 6
Juan Lopez - 5
La Flor De Cano - 4
La Gloria Cubana - 6
Montecristo - 7
Partagas - 8
Por Larranaga - 7
Punch - 6
Quintero - 2
Rafael Gonzalez - 7
Ramon Allones - 13
Romeo y Julieta - 7
Saint Luis Rey - 6
San Cristobal de La Habana - 6
Sancho Panza - 6

Out

21 Vegueros
22 Vegas Robaina
23 Trinidad
24 Cuaba
25 Fonseca
26 Quai d'Orsay
27 Jose L Pedra

[MarkLondon]

Are the vegueros no good generally or is it because they are still young? Not tried one myself.

[Matt1979]

For today I'd to vote FOR Quinteros for it being a wonderful smoke for the price. And against Vegueros.

[RDBM]

-2 for cohiba after yesterday's experience with an unsmokeable Maduro 5 and +1 for Allones.

RG +1 Quintero -1
Bolivar - 12
Cohiba - 3
(24 Cuaba)
Diplomaticos - 6
El Rey del Mundo - 6
(25 Fonseca)
H Upmann - 5
Hoyo de Monterrey - 6
(27 Jose L Pedra)
Juan Lopez - 5
La Flor De Cano - 4*
La Gloria Cubana - 6
Montecristo - 7
Partagas - 8
Por Larranaga - 7
Punch - 6
(26 Quai d'Orsay)
Quintero - 3
Rafael Gonzalez - 7
Ramon Allones - 13
Romeo y Julieta - 7
Saint Luis Rey - 6
San Cristobal de La Habana - 6
Sancho Panza - 6
(23 Trinidad)
(22 Vegas Robaina)
Vegueros - 0

[Simon Bolivar]

RG +1 Quintero -1
Bolivar - 12
Cohiba - 5
(24 Cuaba)
Diplomaticos - 6
El Rey del Mundo - 6
(25 Fonseca)
H Upmann - 5
Hoyo de Monterrey - 6
(27 Jose L Pedra)
Juan Lopez - 5
La Flor De Cano - 4*
La Gloria Cubana - 6
Montecristo - 7
Partagas - 8
Por Larranaga - 7
Punch - 6
(26 Quai d'Orsay)
Quintero - 3
Rafael Gonzalez - 7
Ramon Allones - 12
Romeo y Julieta - 7
Saint Luis Rey - 6
San Cristobal de La Habana - 6
Sancho Panza - 6
(23 Trinidad)
(22 Vegas Robaina)
Vegueros - 0*

[Wigan]

Yes I agree too actually. I just think hey are massively overpriced.

[Stevieboy]

I forget which member said it but its better to buy less but buy better

monkey66 and I agree 100%

[sheppsea]

you can buy a handful of quintero for a single cohiba. working it out per cigar they are worse in my eyes and this all about seeing how other people view cigars

I suppose the question is whether you would prefer a handful of cheaper smokes or one more expensive one - for me I would rather have one top smoke a week than five cheaper ones; I forget which member said it but its better to buy less but buy better

That not necessarily saying more expensive is always better of course

[Stevieboy]

Bolivar - 12
Cohiba - 5
(24 Cuaba)
Diplomaticos - 6
El Rey del Mundo - 6
(25 Fonseca)
H Upmann - 5
Hoyo de Monterrey - 6
(27 Jose L Pedra)
Juan Lopez - 5
La Flor De Cano - 4*
La Gloria Cubana - 6
Montecristo - 7
Partagas - 8
Por Larranaga - 7
Punch - 6
(26 Quai d'Orsay)
Quintero - 4
Rafael Gonzalez - 6
Ramon Allones - 12
Romeo y Julieta - 7
Saint Luis Rey - 6
San Cristobal de La Habana - 6
Sancho Panza - 6
(23 Trinidad)
(22 Vegas Robaina)
Vegueros - 0

+1 Juan Lopez
-2 LFdC

[Stevieboy]

Bolivar - 12
Cohiba - 5
(24 Cuaba)
Diplomaticos - 6
El Rey del Mundo - 6
(25 Fonseca)
H Upmann - 5
Hoyo de Monterrey - 6
(27 Jose L Pedra)
Juan Lopez - 5
La Flor De Cano - 4*
La Gloria Cubana - 6
Montecristo - 7
Partagas - 8
Por Larranaga - 7
Punch - 6
(26 Quai d'Orsay)
Quintero - 4
Rafael Gonzalez - 6
Ramon Allones - 12
Romeo y Julieta - 7
Saint Luis Rey - 6
San Cristobal de La Habana - 6
Sancho Panza - 6
(23 Trinidad)
(22 Vegas Robaina)
Vegueros - 0*

+1 Juan Lopez
-2 LFdC

[cigarmo]

Bolivar - 12
Cohiba - 5
(24 Cuaba)
Diplomaticos - 6
El Rey del Mundo - 6
(25 Fonseca)
H Upmann - 5
Hoyo de Monterrey - 6
(27 Jose L Pedra)
Juan Lopez - 4
La Flor De Cano - 6
La Gloria Cubana - 6
Montecristo - 7*
Partagas - 8
Por Larranaga - 7
Punch - 6
(26 Quai d'Orsay)
Quintero - 4
Rafael Gonzalez - 6
Ramon Allones - 12
Romeo y Julieta - 7
Saint Luis Rey - 6
San Cristobal de La Habana - 6
Sancho Panza - 6
(23 Trinidad)
(22 Vegas Robaina)
Vegueros - 0*